Comparison

Cricut Maker vs Maker 4: Should You Upgrade? (November 2026)

Updated on · By the Handyloom team

Upgrade to Maker 4 if faster cutting and a fresh bundle fit your needs; keep the original Maker if it already handles your projects. Both work with a wide range of materials and tools.

On this page (6 sections)
  1. Cricut Maker vs Maker 4: what changes?
  2. Should original Maker owners upgrade?
  3. Which Maker 4 bundle suits your projects?
  4. How does Maker 5 compare with Maker 4?
  5. What should you consider before switching machines?
  6. Cricut Maker vs Maker 4: which should you choose?

Upgrade to Maker 4 if faster cutting and a fresh bundle fit your needs; keep the original Maker if it already handles your projects.

In this Cricut Maker vs Maker 4 comparison, the key question is whether the newer machine changes your daily work enough to justify replacing a functioning cutter. Cricut says Maker 4 cuts up to 2X faster than the previous model.

That figure is a stated maximum, so it helps to think about where your own time actually goes. If you make single cards or occasional labels, design time and weeding may take more of your session than cutting time.

If you repeat the same design in batches, a faster cut can add up across many repeats. It is worth timing a few recent projects before you decide.

Note how long setup, material preparation, cutting, weeding and finishing each took. Then ask whether faster cutting would have changed the total in a way you would notice.

If you're new to cutting machines, start with what a vinyl cutting machine does. This comparison is for original Maker owners weighing the upgrade, with newer Maker 4 bundles to show what a fresh start could include.

A bundle matters because it shapes what you can try in the first weeks of ownership. Look at the materials, mat, pen and tools included rather than the bundle name alone.

Some bundles focus on sample materials, while others center on card making or heat transfer. Choosing supplies you will actually use makes a new machine easier to settle into and reduces the chance of paying for items that sit unused in a drawer.

Check which tools you already own before you assume a bundle completes your setup. Maker 4 works with 300+ materials, including leather, wood, vinyl, iron-on HTV, cardstock and stickers.

That range is useful when a project needs a material your current setup does not cover. It is less useful as a reason to replace a machine that already handles your regular list.

Specialty tools for tasks such as engraving or foiling may be sold separately, so plan for that cost. Design Space connects to the machine and offers a free content library to get started.

The free library includes 3,000+ images and 100+ fonts, while a paid subscription opens more content. Decide early whether the free designs fit the projects you plan to make, as that choice affects both your first projects and the long term value of the upgrade.

Keep notes on the projects you want to make in the next few months. A clear project list makes the upgrade choice easier to judge.

Cricut MakerBest for a simple Maker 4 start

Cricut Maker

9.6/10Our score

See it on Amazon

Cricut Maker® 5 Essential Bundle + DigitalBest for a larger starter supply

Cricut Maker® 5 Essential Bundle + Digital

9.5/10Our score

See it on Amazon

Cricut Maker vs Maker 4: what changes?

Maker 4's clearest stated change is cutting speed, with the newer machine described as up to 2X faster than the previous model. The available details don't guarantee a broad feature gap for every craft or material.

Maker 4 works with 300+ materials and compatible tools for cutting, drawing, foiling, scoring, engraving, debossing and perforating. Those capabilities are useful when your projects move beyond vinyl and paper, but an original Maker owner should first check whether the current machine already supports the work they do.

The Maker 4 bundle also changes what you get at the start. Some options include sample materials and a pen, while others focus on card making or heat-transfer projects.

Is the speed difference useful in daily crafting?

The speed claim matters most if you repeat cuts or make projects in batches. For occasional labels or single cards, setup and design time may matter more than the machine's cutting speed.

A faster cut doesn't remove the time needed to prepare material, select tools, weed a design or apply a transfer. Think about where your crafting time goes before treating speed as the deciding factor.

If you often cut several of the same design, Maker 4's stated speed may make a more noticeable difference. If projects vary and you make them one at a time, keeping the original Maker may be the practical choice.

Do you need Maker 4's material range?

Keep the original Maker if it already handles your materials and project types. Maker 4's 300+ material range is a reason to consider it when a specific new material or tool capability matters to you.

Cricut describes Maker 4 as supporting tasks such as cutting, writing, foiling, scoring, engraving, debossing and perforating. Some specialty tools are sold separately, so don't assume a machine bundle includes every tool needed for those tasks.

Check your own project list: vinyl decals, paper crafts, fabric work, engraving or heat-transfer designs. If your current setup covers that list, a new model may not change what you can make enough to justify the switch.

Should original Maker owners upgrade?

Upgrade when you can name a practical benefit you will use, such as the stated speed increase or a bundle with supplies for planned projects. Keep your original Maker if it meets your needs and you don't have a clear reason to replace it.

The decision isn't just about machine generation. A bundle can save setup shopping if you need its included materials, but it can also add items you won't use.

Compare the Cricut Maker vs Maker 3 upgrade question if Maker 3 is another machine you're considering. That helps put the Maker 4 choice in context with the middle generation.

What to check before replacing a working machine

Make a short list of the projects you want to make in the next few months. Note the materials, tools and any heat-transfer steps each one needs.

Then check which needs your original Maker already meets. If the only difference you can identify is a newer model name, wait until a real project requirement gives the upgrade a purpose.

A broken or unreliable machine may change the calculation, but don't assume that replacing it with Maker 4 will solve an issue without checking the cause. Setup, material choice and tool selection can also affect a cut.

Which Maker 4 bundle suits your projects?

Choose the bundle by its included supplies and the projects you expect to make, not by the word “bundle.” The Maker 4 options here share a machine generation but package different starting materials and tools.

The seashell Maker 4 bundle suits a crafter who wants a varied sample set for trying vinyl, iron-on, cardstock and transfer tape. It also includes 30 bonus images in Design Space, so you can start with digital designs alongside the physical materials.

The optional Cricut Access subscription is separate. The free content library includes 3,000+ images and 100+ fonts, while the paid subscription opens the full library.

Choose the Ultimate Card Making Kit if cards are a frequent project and you'd use the included card supplies. Its bundle also includes vinyl, iron-on, Infusible Ink, tools and mats, so it can support more than greeting cards.

Maker 4 works with Smart Materials for continuous cuts up to 12 ft without a mat, according to the product description. That can suit longer designs, but confirm that the material and project you plan to use are compatible.

This bundle makes more sense if you plan to cut designs and apply them to items such as the included tote blank. If you don't need a heat press or pressing supplies, those additions may not make it a better fit than a simpler Maker 4 package.

For more bundle comparisons, see our best Cricut Maker bundle guide. If you already own a Maker and only need to add tools or materials, compare Cricut Maker accessories before replacing the machine.

How does Maker 5 compare with Maker 4?

Maker 5 is a separate model to compare, not another name for Maker 4. Its Essential Bundle is described as 30% more compact than previous models and retains 12 in cutting performance.

The Maker 5 bundle works with 300+ materials and includes a Premium Fine Point Cutting Tool, Scoring Tool, Engraving Tool, printable vinyl, insert card sets and other supplies.

Its stated 12 in (30.5 cm) cutting performance helps set expectations for the working width.

That width suits many everyday designs, but check your larger projects before you commit.

Cricut describes this model as working with 13 tools, with specialty tools sold separately.

That means the tool list can cover cutting, engraving, writing, drawing, foiling, scoring and debossing.

You still need to confirm which tools are in the box and which ones you would add later.

The bundle includes supplies for up to 65 projects, based on an average project size of 4 x 6 in using the included materials.

That estimate is a guide, not a promise for larger or more complex designs.

Smaller projects may use less material, while repeated large cuts can use it faster.

Choose it if those supplies and the more compact design suit your workspace and project mix.

A smaller footprint can help on a crowded desk, especially if you also store materials nearby.

If your goal is specifically to move from the original Maker to Maker 4, compare the Maker 4 bundles directly instead of treating Maker 5 as an automatic substitute.

The two models differ in bundle contents and design, so match the choice to your project list.

What should you consider before switching machines?

Plan for the whole crafting setup, including the app, materials, workspace and tools. A machine upgrade is most useful when it fits the way you design and make projects.

Maker 4 works with the Design Space app, and its bundle includes digital images that become available after machine registration. Some content and software features require a paid Cricut Access subscription, so decide whether the free content and features cover your needs.

Before buying, write down the tools you already own and the supplies included in the bundle you're considering. This helps avoid duplicating tools or choosing a package around materials you don't plan to use.

How do you get started with Maker 4?

Set up the machine through Cricut's instructions and Design Space, then make a small practice project with a material from your bundle. A simple first cut helps you learn the workflow before you commit to a larger design.

Our Maker 4 setup guide walks through its basic use. If you keep the earlier model, follow the Maker 3 setup guide for a similar generation-specific walkthrough.

For either machine, use the correct material and tool for the project, and follow the setup instructions. Store loose materials flat and keep the machine and work area clear of scraps between projects.

What if you want to keep the original Maker?

Keep using it for the projects it already handles, and revisit the upgrade only when a real need appears. You can learn a new material or improve your workflow without replacing the machine first.

Our Cricut Explore 3 guide can also help if you're comparing a different Cricut workflow for basic cutting tasks. For original Maker owners, the goal is to match the machine to the projects you make rather than upgrade on a schedule.

For another Cricut workflow, see using Cricut Explore Air 2.

Cricut Maker vs Maker 4: which should you choose?

Keep the original Maker if it meets your current needs; choose Maker 4 if its stated speed or a specific bundle solves a problem you have.

Choose Maker 5 only if its distinct bundle and compact design fit your plans better. Start by listing the projects you make most often and the materials each one needs.

Include the tools you use for those projects, such as cutting, scoring, writing or engraving tools. Mark the needs your original Maker already meets without difficulty.

That simple list often shows whether an upgrade would add a real capability or only a newer model name. If your current machine struggles with a specific material, note that material and the tool it requires.

Maker 4 works with 300+ materials, so check whether that specific need is covered. Also check whether the tool for that task is included or sold separately.

A bundle can change the value of the decision in practical ways. The Maker 4 starter bundle suits varied craft projects, the card kit favors card making, and the Engagement Plus bundle adds heat-transfer supplies.

For those projects, see how to use heat transfer vinyl. Compare the included items against what you already own before choosing.

Avoid paying twice for mats, pens or tools you already have and still use. Look instead for supplies that fill gaps in your current setup.

A card focused kit makes sense if cards are a regular part of your crafting. A heat transfer bundle makes more sense if you plan to press designs onto items such as tote bags.

Store loose materials flat so they stay ready for a clean cut. Keep the machine and work area clear of scraps between projects, and use the correct material and tool for each project.

Design Space offers free content to start, with more available through an optional paid subscription. Decide whether that free library covers your style before you rely on added content.

If you still need a cutting machine, review the vinyl cutting machine buying guide for broader selection advice. If your current Maker works well, the upgrade decision can wait until a new project gives it a clear job.

Frequently asked questions

Is Cricut Maker 4 worth upgrading from the original Maker?

Maker 4 can be worth upgrading if you want its stated cutting speed of up to 2X the previous model or need a new bundle of materials and tools. If your original Maker already handles your projects, compare the cost of replacing it with the value of that speed and any supplies you would use.

Can the original Cricut Maker still handle many materials?

The original Maker remains a capable choice if it supports the materials and tools your projects require. Maker 4 is described as working with 300+ materials and compatible with 13 tools, but decide from the specific materials and tool setup you use rather than the model name alone.

What comes with a Cricut Maker 4 bundle?

It depends on the bundle. One Maker 4 option includes a Fine-Point Blade, sample materials, a pen, a mat, a weeder and 30 bonus images; another adds card-making supplies, while an Engagement Plus bundle includes a heat press, pressing mat and tote blank.

Does Cricut Maker 4 cut faster than the original Maker?

Cricut describes Maker 4 as cutting up to 2X faster than the previous model. Actual project time also depends on the design, material, tool and settings, so treat that figure as a stated maximum rather than a promise that every job takes half as long.

Should I choose Maker 4 or Maker 5?

Choose based on the bundle and machine details you need. Maker 4 has bundles focused on sample materials, card making or heat-transfer projects; Maker 5 is a different model with 12 in cutting performance and an Essential Bundle described as supplying up to 65 projects.